Setting up an irrevocable life insurance trust (ILIT) can be a smart move for estate planning. But questions often pop up about the roles inside these trusts—like, can a beneficiary also be the trustee? The answer isn’t always black and white, and it’s packed with implications that could shape your financial legacy.
Understanding the Basics of an ILIT
An ILIT is a legal structure that owns a life insurance policy. Its main goal is to keep the death benefit out of the insured person’s taxable estate. This helps protect your family’s wealth from unnecessary taxes when you’re gone.
Once the trust is set up and funded, no one—not even the person who created it (the grantor)—can change the terms. The trust’s assets are locked away, managed by a trustee for the benefit of the trust’s named beneficiaries.
Photo by Kampus Production
Can a Beneficiary Legally Be a Trustee?
There’s no legal rule stopping a beneficiary from acting as trustee of an ILIT. The law lets you choose almost any responsible adult, except the grantor, to serve as trustee—even someone who will benefit from the trust.
But just because something is allowed doesn't always make it wise. This decision has real consequences you can’t afford to ignore.
Fiduciary Duty and Possible Conflicts
When a beneficiary is also the trustee, there’s an added layer of responsibility. The trustee must always act in the best interest of all beneficiaries—not just themselves. Think of this like playing referee while also being one of the players. It's easy to forget which hat you’re wearing.
Why This Can Be a Problem
- Conflict of Interest: If there are several beneficiaries, a trustee who is also a beneficiary might favor themselves, even without meaning to.
- Family Disagreements: This setup can lead to suspicions or real arguments about fairness if others feel left out.
- Legal Exposure: Trustees who don't stick to their duty open themselves up to lawsuits and trust disputes.
Tax and Estate Planning Risks
The main purpose of an ILIT—to keep life insurance out of your taxable estate—can get derailed if the trustee isn’t chosen carefully.
When to Avoid a Beneficiary as Trustee
- Grantor as Trustee: Never choose the person who set up the trust to be trustee. This will pull the insurance policy back into their estate, undoing the tax savings.
- Spouse as Trustee: If your spouse is both a trustee and beneficiary, the IRS may treat the trust assets as if they belong to your estate or theirs.
Even if a child or another relative is both trustee and beneficiary, they shouldn’t have too much control. The more power they have—like being able to use trust money for anything they want—the greater the risk for estate taxes.
Best Practices for Choosing a Trustee
Picking the right trustee is key to making sure your plan works as intended.
- Choose a Neutral Party: This might be a trusted family friend, a relative who’s not a beneficiary, or a professional like a corporate trustee.
- Limit Powers: If a beneficiary must serve as trustee, carefully limit their powers, especially over how and when they distribute money.
- Get Good Legal Documents: Work with an attorney who knows ILITs to set clear rules in the trust.
Pros and Cons of a Beneficiary Serving as Trustee
Balancing personal and family interests is never simple, but knowing the trade-offs helps you make smart choices.
Pros:
- The trustee will likely have a stake in making sure things run smoothly.
- It can keep costs down, since corporate trustees charge fees.
Cons:
- Higher risk for family conflict.
- More chances for legal trouble if handling isn't perfectly fair.
- Loss of tax benefits if rules aren’t followed to the letter.
What Trusts Like ILITs Mean For Your Family
ILITs offer more than just tax perks. They’re a shield that keeps life insurance proceeds safe from creditors, protects privacy, and gives peace of mind. But a smart structure is a must—one wrong move and your plan could backfire.
Conclusion
Having a beneficiary serve as trustee of an irrevocable life insurance trust is possible, but it brings real challenges. While the law allows it, practical risks—like conflicts of interest and tax pitfalls—should make you pause before putting a beneficiary in charge.
A neutral trustee, paired with strong legal advice, is often the safest route. Carefully weigh the benefits against the risks for your unique family situation.
If you’re setting up an ILIT or have questions about trust roles, talk to a professional who guides you through the options. Your family’s legacy deserves nothing less than a plan that stands the test of time.